Many of the works in Ridley Scott’s diverse filmography are rightfully regarded as great movies, but some don’t get nearly as much attention as they deserve, with Matchstick Men standing out as the director’s most underrated movie.
The sci-fi genre owes a lot to Ridley Scott, because Ellen Ripley, a character who helped reshape genre expectations, would likely have never become the trailblazing feminist icon she is without Sigourney Weaver’s dedication to the role and Scott’s own pᴀssion for challenging the status quo through his work when he wrote and directed his sophomore feature, Alien, in 1979.
We also ᴀssociate the historical epic genre with Ridley Scott because, despite the changes to the true story of Roman history that it’s based on, Gladiator has had an undeniable cultural impact. House of Gucci, Napoleon, The Last Duel, and Robin Hood are among the other noteworthy contributions. He’s given us incredible runs through the best years in movie history.
We ᴀssociate him with the cult classic dark fantasy movie Legend, his other sci-fi classic Blade Runner, the quintessential road trip film Thelma & Louise, again featuring trailblazing feminist icons, the crime films Body of Lies and American Gangster, and the war films G.I. Jane and Black Hawk Down. However, one crime film is still underrated despite its star power.
Matchstick Men Is (Probably) Ridley Scott’s Most Underrated Movie
It is inevitable for a man with such a large filmography as Ridley Scott to have a few underrated movies that don’t get the attention they deserve, but Scott’s cinema has consistently received a level of attention because of his reputation and his mastery of the medium. However, Matchstick Men barely made a splash in 2003 when it came out.
Matchstick Men stars Nicolas Cage and Sam Rockwell as main characters. Alison Lohman appears in the supporting role of the former’s daughter, alongside Bruce Altman as his therapist. With Scott directing, the film had enough star power for it to be a big deal in the early 2000s, but it flew under the audience’s radar, and continues to do so.
Scott is known for challenging the status quo with his works, especially by subverting tropes and experimenting with the form to tell unique stories. In that thread, Matchstick Men is neither a fast-paced heist/conman thriller, nor a poignant and slow drama about redemption, but a mix of the two held together to tell a compelling story, thanks to Scott’s expertise.
Roy Waller and Frank Mercer, played by Cage and Rockwell respectively, are two conmen whose biggest challenge is the former’s long list of phobias, for which he sees Dr. Klein (Altman). However, their work is further complicated by the arrival of Angela (Lohman), Roy’s daughter from his previous relationship 14 years ago. The film follows Roy as his life unravels.
The perfect balance between the dramatic storyline of being a good parent while being a conman and the thrill of the actual conning sequences makes Matchstick Men the best Ridley Scott movie that you have not heard of. Scott performs a character study through the film’s premise that interrogates the typical heroism and straightforward storytelling ᴀssociated with this crime subgenre.
Matchstick Men Contains One Of Nicolas Cage’s Best Performances
Apart from agoraphobia and a possible form of OCD, Nicolas Cage’s Roy Waller has many tics triggered by commonplace occurrences, which make it difficult for him to conduct business and leave his house for work without medication. While the medication becomes a source of tension and the subject of a great plot twist, Roy’s condition is central to the film.
Nicolas Cage transforms into Roy. Roy’s tics don’t seem performative, and you’d be excused for thinking Cage developed those tics after he played Charlie Kaufman in Adaptation (2002) and before hs started shooting scenes for Matchstick Men. He is unbelievably natural in his depiction of these behavioral pecularities that would seem like a caricature in the hands of a less capable actor.
The Nouveau Shamanic style of acting that Cage developed and popularized is known for extending one’s imagination so as to believe they’re personally experiencing the same events as their character, is on full display in Matchstick Men. From eye twitches and involuntary winks to characteristic grunts, Roy feels like a real individual because of Nicolas Cage’s commitment to the role.
What makes Matchstick Men one of Ridley Scott’s most rewatchable movies is Nicolas Cage’s dedicated performance as Roy. While the tics are the highlights of his performance, he’s also natural and warm in the redemption arc driven by his wish to be a good father. Roy’s crisis of faith and love for his daughter are this personable because of him.
Why Matchstick Men Doesn’t Have A Bigger Legacy In 2025
One of the major reasons Matchstick Men‘s legacy is tarnished is because Hans Zimmer never returned to directly compose music for Ridley after their rift while working on Matchstick Men. However, that would have made the film infamous and kept in the zeitgeist, instead of being remembered as the movie that was always on TV but no one actually watched.
Despite making many noteworthy movies in the past 25 years, Ridley Scott has struggled to find as much success for his films as 2000’s Gladiator.
So, the better explanation is that it’s overshadowed. The film underperformed at the box office, despite it being released after Hannibal and Black Hawk Down, and that’s possibly because a small-scale comedy-drama was conceptually underwhelming despite the cast. In later years, it’s faded further from prominence because it doesn’t fit snugly in any of Scott’s most popular categories of movies.
Matchstick Men deserves better because of its fantastic twist ending, Nicolas Cage’s brilliant performance, the approach to conman filmmaking, Hans Zimmer’s score, and Ridley Scott’s deliberate direction. However, such a small-scale film is so rare for 2000s Nicolas Cage or Ridley Scott in any decade, who mostly directs epically grand films, that it’ll likely never have the legacy it deserves.
