Pirates of the Caribbean 6 is on the way, and while it is set to be a new take on the franchise, the film has already missed its most exciting opportunity with this A-list star. The Pirates of the Caribbean franchise is one of the biggest in movie history, and now that it has been eight years since the previous film, progress is finally being made on the sequel.

After the release of Pirates of the Caribbean: ᴅᴇᴀᴅ Men Tell No Tales, the future of the franchise was a bit uncertain. The real-life controversies surrounding Johnny Depp and the franchise’s decreasing success put Pirates of the Caribbean in a state of flux. All kinds of ideas were thrown around, including fully rebooting Pirates of the Caribbean with new characters.

However, a proper Pirates of the Caribbean 6 is finally happening. Franchise producer Jerry Bruckheimer has confirmed that Pirates of the Caribbean 6 will have some returning characters, although it isn’t yet known who will appear. While this is immensely exciting, it isn’t as exciting as this previously released idea for Pirates of the Caribbean 6.

Pirates Of The Caribbean Will Be A “New Take,” But Not A Total Reboot

According To Jerry Bruckheimer

Jerry Bruckheimer has just revealed a bit more about Pirates of the Caribbean 6, with him saying that the upcoming film will “be a new take on” the franchise. This came in response to Screen Rant asking whether or not Pirates of the Caribbean 6 will continue the story of the previous films or if it will be something new, with Bruckheimer using this response to not fully confirm or deny either possibility.

Bruckheimer’s comment, combined with the fact that some previous Pirates of the Caribbean characters will be returning, means that Pirates of the Caribbean 6 won’t be a total reboot. This means that fans of the original film will probably still be able to enjoy the upcoming film as part of the broader franchise, while newcomers won’t be punished for not seeing the less well-received films.

Taking all of this together, it seems most likely that Pirates of the Caribbean 6 will be a legacy sequel. Following in the footsteps of films like Top Gun: Maverick, Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny, and Star Wars: The Force Awakens, Pirates of the Caribbean 6 will probably continue the broad themes and arcs of the franchise without getting too into the specifics of more unpopular stories.

Margot Robbie’s Movie Was The Most Exciting Future For Pirates Of The Caribbean

Even More So Than Pirates Of The Caribbean 6

While a continuation of the previous saga is exciting, Margot Robbie’s Pirates of the Caribbean 6 was the most exciting future for the franchise. On May 20, 2024, Jerry Bruckheimer gave some news about Pirates of the Caribbean 6. He revealed that two scripts for the upcoming film were in the works, one of which was a reboot, and the other was a film starring Margot Robbie.

Having Margot Robbie as the lead of a Pirates of the Caribbean movie is incredibly exciting, as she is one of the most popular actresses working in Hollywood today. She has proven that she can lead action franchises thanks to her role as Harley Quinn in the DCU, and her blockbuster star status was further cemented by the release of Barbie.

Margot Robbie’s involvement could have brought a lot of attention back to the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise in a way that just another sequel couldn’t. Robbie’s name has become synonymous with quality, and after major critical successes like The Suicide Squad, Barbie, I, Tonya, and more, it would have meant a lot for her to be involved.

Why Margot Robbie’s POTC Isn’t Happening – And Could It Be Revived?

What Has Been Said About The Film’s Cancellation

Unfortunately, Margot Robbie’s Pirates of the Caribbean movie no longer seems to be happening. In November 2022, Margot Robbie confirmed that her Pirates of the Caribbean movie would not be moving forward, killing the film. Robbie implied that Disney was no longer interested in the film, and that she really wanted to do it despite its cancellation.

However, that announcement may not be the end for the film. Later, Jerry Bruckheimer revealed that Margot Robbie’s Pirates of the Caribbean was still in the works, and that “We hope to get ’em both made” despite the sequel taking priority. So, it is possible that the Margot Robbie film could be revived.

There have also been rumors of a Pirates of the Caribbean film starring The Bear‘s Ayo Edebiri. There has been no definitive confirmation whether Edebiri is meant to replace Robbie in her female-led Pirates movie or if Edebiri was being eyed for an entirely different film. However, things are looking up for Robbie’s Pirates of the Caribbean.

Disney Really Needs To Get Pirates Of The Caribbean 6 Right

A Lot Is Riding On It

After the lengthy development cycle of the film, Disney really needs to get Pirates of the Caribbean 6 right. There seems to be a lot riding on the upcoming film, as the female-led spinoff and potential for more sequels all depend on the upcoming movie.

The last two Pirates of the Caribbean films have been major disappointments, and after eight years, Disney can’t afford to mess it up again. Another failure would probably be the final nail in the coffin for the franchise, meaning that Pirates of the Caribbean 6 has to be a critical and commercial hit.