I Can’t Believe It’s Taken Me 20 Years To Realize Palpatine Was Totally Lying About Darth Plagueis

Emperor Palpatine used every possible tactic to manipulate Anakin Skywalker in the Star Wars prequel trilogy, but his lies about Sith Lord Darth Plagueis were especially twisted. Palpatine understood that Anakin was driven by love and attachment. Anakin’s love for his mother caused him to commit a terrifyingly violent mᴀssacre, and his love and fear for his secret wife, Padmé Amidala, sent him spiraling into the darkness.

In perhaps one of the most quoted scenes from Star Wars: Episode III – Revenge of the Sith, Palpatine pushes Anakin to the edge by promising him the ultimate secret of the dark side: how to use the Force to save people from death. Anakin’s dreams about Padmé’s mortal fate were traumatizing him, and he was desperate to keep her alive.

“Did you ever hear the tragedy of Darth Plagueis the Wise? It’s not a story the Jedi would tell you. It’s a Sith legend. Darth Plagueis was a dark lord of the Sith; so powerful and so wise, he could use the Force to influence midi-chlorians to create life. He had such a knowledge of the dark side, he could even keep the ones he cared about from dying.”

Of course, we know that Palpatine never actually intended to help Anakin save Padmé. Her death was a driving force behind Anakin’s rage and fear, both of which fueled his hunger for the dark side of the Force and his transformation into Darth Vader.

What stands out to me in Revenge of the Sith’s opera house scene isn’t just that Palpatine was lying to Anakin about wanting to save Padmé. What bothers me most is Palpatine’s wording and the cruelty of his reconstructed version of Plagueis’ legacy.

There’s One Big Problem With Palpatine’s Plagueis Tale

Palpatine talks to Anakin in Revenge of the Sith.

As Tumblr user david-talks-sw so joyfully pointed out, the Sith are generally incapable of caring about people. They are painfully, disgustingly self-absorbed, motivated solely by their lust for power. “He could even keep the ones he cared about from dying” is a blatant lie, because a Sith Lord as powerful as Darth Plagueis never truly worried about or cared for anyone but themselves.

The real tragedy here is that Anakin was so blinded by his fear of Padmé’s death that he couldn’t recognize that Palpatine was manipulating him. Surely, Anakin had learned about the Sith from the Jedi. Was he truly so far gone that he couldn’t see, couldn’t sense, that Palpatine, like all Sith, was twisting the truth for his personal gain?

Though the Jedi’s rules against attachment were, in some cases, much too restrictive, they did hit the nail on the head with Anakin. Palpatine used Anakin’s attachment effectively. Anakin was so desperate, all Palpatine needed at that point were a few pretty, carefully curated words, and the young Jedi Knight was putty in his hands.

Palpatine’s Tale Was Half-True, Though

While Palpatine undoubtedly lied about Plagueis’ reasons for experimenting with the dark side, part of his well-spun tale was true. Plagueis never fully managed to cheat the physical death of his body. He did, however, discover the secrets of essence transfer, a way of preserving his spirit and consciousness by transferring them to another host.

Plagueis may never have discovered how to become immortal in his own body, but he did find a way to preserve the only thing he ever truly loved: himself.

Essentially, this meant the Sith Lord’s mind could live on forever. For all Plagueis’ wisdom, though, he foolishly told his apprentice, Darth Sidious, a.k.a. Emperor Palpatine, about this dark side power, and Sidious killed his Master. He then used Plagueis’ technique to survive in multiple cloned bodies, resulting in his surprise resurrection in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker.

Plagueis may never have discovered how to become immortal in his own body, but he did find a way to preserve the only thing he ever truly loved: himself. That’s not the solution that Anakin was hoping for, however. Time and again, Emperor Palpatine proved just how unscrupulous and horrible he truly was.

Source: david-talks-sw on Tumblr

Upcoming Star Wars Movies

Release Date

The Mandalorian and Grogu

May 22, 2026

Star Wars: Starfighter

May 28, 2027

Ian McDiarmid as Emperor Palpatine in Star Wars Return of the Jedi

Created By

George Lucas

Cast

Ian McDiarmid, Sam Witwer, Ian Abercrombie

First Appearance

Star Wars: Episode V – The Empire Strikes Back

Died

Star Wars: Episode IX- The Rise Of Skywalker

Alliance

Sith, Empire

Race

Human


Related Posts

Tim Burton’s Next Movie Is Something I’ve Wanted For 13 Years & It’s Better Than Beetlejuice 3

Tim Burton’s Next Movie Is Something I’ve Wanted For 13 Years & It’s Better Than Beetlejuice 3

Tim Burton has already announced his next movie project, and the news of this project that I’ve wanted for 13 years is already better than Beetlejuice 3….

The Two Horrific Real-Life Racing Crashes That Inspired F1’s Most Chilling Scene

The Two Horrific Real-Life Racing Crashes That Inspired F1’s Most Chilling Scene

Warning: The following contains spoilers for F1: The Movie.F1: The Movie director Joseph Kosinski reveals the two real-life incidents that inspired the most jaw-dropping moment in the…

Sequel To Denzel Washington’s 30-Year-Old War Thriller May Continue A Big Career Shift

Sequel To Denzel Washington’s 30-Year-Old War Thriller May Continue A Big Career Shift

Despite some erroneous reports that he was retiring, Denzel Washington has continued to have an active career into his septuagenarian era. Last year, he played a key…

Michael Douglas, 80, Addresses Retirement Plans & Future: “No Real Intentions Of Going Back”

Michael Douglas, 80, Addresses Retirement Plans & Future: “No Real Intentions Of Going Back”

Veteran actor Michael Douglas, who had, back in 1975, produced One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, a film featuring one of the best Oscar-winning actor performances ever,…

Karate Kid: Legends Was A Bad Idea From Day 1 – No One Can Be Surprised The 59% RT Sequel Didn’t Work

Karate Kid: Legends Was A Bad Idea From Day 1 – No One Can Be Surprised The 59% RT Sequel Didn’t Work

Karate Kid: Legends is the latest entry in The Karate Kid franchise, and while some people are fans of the sequel, it was a bad idea from…

Two Live-Action Remakes’ .4Bn Success Begins A New Hollywood Trend

Two Live-Action Remakes’ $1.4Bn Success Begins A New Hollywood Trend

2025’s Lilo & Sтιтch and How to Train Your Dragon could be responsible for a major new Hollywood trend thanks to their combined box office success. Both…