Star Trek Deserved An Oscar 45 Years Ago, But Lost To A Much Better Sci-Fi Movie

The first Star Trek movie seemed poised to snag an Oscar in 1980, but it lost out to a far superior science fiction film. The Star Trek film franchise got off to a slow start with the release of The Motion Picture. Essentially the gap between eras, it was incredibly mixed and largely failed to impress audiences and critics.

Fortunately, the Enterprise crew returned for another adventure a few years later, and The Wrath of Khan put the franchise back on the right course. Critical achievement and box office success came in tandem for most of the Star Trek sequels throughout the ’80s and early ’90s, and Trek even returned to TV in the late ’80s as well.

Because Star Trek is first and foremost a science fiction series, its chances of winning major movie awards are somewhat diminished. However, the Academy Awards does feature quite a few technical categories that are specifically suited for effects-heavy spectacles. Despite releasing a new movie every few years for over 20 years, Star Trek didn’t fare in those either.

The Star Trek movie franchise has lost a lot of Oscars, including the more recent films by J.J. Abrams, but its first loss is particularly powerful. Star Trek: The Motion Picture might be one of the worst of the Star Trek movies, but its Academy Awards failure 45 years ago came at the hands of another sci-fi franchise starter.

Star Trek: The Motion Picture Was Nominated For Best Visual Effects In 1980

It Lost All Three Categories It Was Nominated For That Year

Even though Star Trek: The Motion Picture was a disappointment overall, it got a considerable amount of Oscar buzz in certain categories. The movie snagged nominations for Best Art Direction, Best Original Score, and perhaps most importantly, Best Visual Effects. This was a big win for the movie, since its visuals were its strongest ᴀsset.

While the story was somewhat sluggish and the characters behaved oddly, The Motion Picture couldn’t be faulted for its amazing visuals. The camerawork by Richard H. Kline set the tone for the rest of the original Star Trek movies, and he had the difficult task of creating the look for the franchise’s jump to the big screen.

The movie had a lot of hurdles to clear, not the least of which was establishing a new tone, and Kline’s cinematography helped that transition along. What really stole the show was the visual effects, and they had come light-years from the days of Star Trek: The Original Series.

CGI was years away, so the heroic sH๏τs of the USS Enterprise were all created using painstaking miniature work and special pH๏τography.

The space sequences are some of the most beautiful ever put on the big screen, and the practical nature of the work is all the more impressive. CGI was years away, so the heroic sH๏τs of the USS Enterprise were all created using painstaking miniature work and special pH๏τography.

Other effects were crisp, such as the transporter beams and Spock’s journey into V’ger. The extended sequence towards the end of the film borrowed heavily from 2001: A Space Odyssey, which ironically won the Best Visual Effects Oscar in 1969. Sadly, Star Trek: The Motion Picture couldn’t repeat that feat, and actually got swept in all three of its categories.

Alien Won The Award Instead Of Star Trek

The Sci-Fi Horror Film Beat Out Star Trek

1979 was an underrated year for science fiction, and Ridley Scott’s extraterrestrial terror, Alien, was the top of its class. The movie was one of the first to truly blend science fiction and horror, and it is a thrilling ride from start to finish. It also helped kick off a franchise that is still going strong to this day.

1980 Best Visual Effects Nominees

Director

Rotten Tomatoes Score

Alien

Ridley Scott

93%

The Black Hole

Gary Nelson

42%

Moonraker

Lewis Gilbert

59%

1941

Steven Spielberg

39%

Star Trek: The Motion Picture

Robert Wise

52%

Alien was also nominated alongside Star Trek: The Motion Picture for Best Visual Effects, and it would eventually win the category. Legendary Swiss artist H.R. Giger and the movie’s special effects team accepted the award, and it was Giger’s art that really gave Alien its iconic look.

Alien was also nominated for Best Art Direction but lost to All That Jazz.

The mix of synthetic and organic designs was unlike anything seen in a film before, and the Xenomorph was a far cry from the rubber-headed alien monsters from previous sci-fi movies. It’s no surprise that Alien beat Star Trek: The Motion Picture, but that’s not to say that the latter didn’t have great effects too.

In a rare bit of forethought from the Academy, Alien won because it wasn’t just an example of strong technical execution, but something never before seen. Star Trek: The Motion Picture was technically perfect, and likely would have won in any other year, but Alien was clearly the better choice at the 1980 Academy Awards.

The Star Trek Franchise Has Endured Bad Luck At The Oscars

Only 1 Win In Nearly 50 Years On The Big Screen

Chris Pine as Captain Kirk sitting on the Enterprise in Star Trek 2009

Since the franchise’s first Oscar nomination in 1980, the Star Trek series has only won one Academy Award. Sadly, none of the classic films won any major awards, and installments like The Wrath of Khan were actually completely snubbed. No Trek film has ever been nominated for categories like Best Picture, but that’s to be expected with sci-fi.

After decades of Oscar heartbreak, Star Trek finally broke through when the 2009 eponymous film by J.J. Abrams won Best Makeup. It was the franchise’s most nominated installment since Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home, but only managed to win one of its four awards.

Even if more Star Trek movies are released in the future, it’s expected that they won’t fare too well at the Academy Awards. Not only are movies like Star Trek not particularly popular with Oscar voters, but there’s a high chance that another film like Alien might come along and snatch up the awards first.

Star Trek Franchise Logo

Created by

Gene Roddenberry

First Film

Star Trek: The Motion Picture

First TV Show

Star Trek: The Original Series

First Episode Air Date

September 8, 1966

Cast

William Shatner, Leonard Nimoy, George Takei, Nichelle Nichols, Deforest Kelley, James Doohan, Walter Koenig, Jonathan Frakes, Patrick Stewart, Michael Dorn, Marina Sirtis, Gates McFadden, Brent Spiner, LeVar Burton, Wil Wheaton, Avery Brooks, Nana Visitor, Rene Auberjonois, Alexander Siddig, Cirroc Lofton, Armin Shimerman, Colm Meaney, Terry Farrell, Kate Mulgrew, Robert Beltran, Roxann Dawson, Jeri Ryan, Robert Duncan McNeill, Robert Picardo, Ethan Phillips, Garrett Wang, Jolene Blalock, Connor Trinneer, Dominic Keating, Scott Bakula, Linda Park, John Billingsley, Anthony Montgomery, Chris Pine, Zachary Quinto, Simon Pegg, Zoe Saldana, Karl Urban, John Cho, Chris Hemsworth, Benedict Cumberbatch, Anton Yelchin, Idris Elba, Sonequa Martin-Green, Mary Wiseman, Doug Jones, Anthony Rapp, Wilson Cruz, Oyin Oladejo, Emily Coutts, Jess Bush, Christina Chong, Anson Mount, Ethan Peck, Rebecca Romijn, Michelle Yeoh

TV Show(s)

Star Trek: The Original Series, Star Trek: The Animated Series, Star Trek: The Next Generation, Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, Star Trek: Voyager, Star Trek: Enterprise, Star Trek: Discovery, Star Trek: Short Treks, Star Trek: Picard, Star Trek Lower Decks, Star Trek: Prodigy, Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, Star Trek: Starfleet Academy


Related Posts

James Gunn’s DCU Update Hints At David Corenswet’s Superman Future Appearance

James Gunn’s DCU Update Hints At David Corenswet’s Superman Future Appearance

As Superman is about to arrive in theaters, James Gunn already has more plans in store for the Man of Steel in the DC Universe. After years…

How Powerful Is Sentry In The MCU Compared To DC’s Superman?

How Powerful Is Sentry In The MCU Compared To DC’s Superman?

Marvel Studios has finally adapted Sentry, who is often dubbed the MCU’s Superman, into live-action, but whether the character is as powerful as the Man of Steel…

New The Fantastic Four: First Steps Clip Gives Glimpse Into Dinner With Marvel’s First Family

New The Fantastic Four: First Steps Clip Gives Glimpse Into Dinner With Marvel’s First Family

A new clip from The Fantastic Four: First Steps outlines dinner time with Marvel’s First Family. The Fantastic Four: First Steps is the final Marvel movie of…

WW2 Battles In Clint Eastwood’s M Box Office Bomb “Accurately Convey The Extent Of The Savage Fighting” Says Marine Corps Leader

WW2 Battles In Clint Eastwood’s $96M Box Office Bomb “Accurately Convey The Extent Of The Savage Fighting” Says Marine Corps Leader

Clint Eastwood’s WWII movie may have been a $65 million box-office bomb, but the battle scenes still get high marks for accuracy from a Marine Corps expert….

Gimli Actor Reveals One Of His Most Hilarious Lines Was Improvised In Lord Of The Rings

Gimli Actor Reveals One Of His Most Hilarious Lines Was Improvised In Lord Of The Rings

The Lord of the Rings star John Rhys-Davies revealed that one of his most hilarious and memorable lines was improvised. Appearing in the celebrated Peter Jackson Lord…

Blumhouse’s M Action Movie Disappointment Is Getting An Unrated Cut

Blumhouse’s $20M Action Movie Disappointment Is Getting An Unrated Cut

M3GAN 2.0 is getting an unrated cut despite being a $20 million box office disappointment. The follow-up to Blumhouse’s sci-fi action movie M3GAN takes place two years…