It was apparent right from the start of Sew Torn that its premise was going to be memorable and unique. The story very quickly introduces the idea of choices by showcasing the same character in three different scenarios, her body still and lifeless in each one. This winds up being the film’s protagonist, Barbara (Eve Connolly), a seamstress struggling to keep business afloat after her mother’s death. Following a brash decision that upsets one of her regular customers, Barbara stumbles into the middle of a crime scene on a desolate road back to her shop.

In the street are two injured men, broken open bags of cocaine, and a mysterious, bulky case. She considers three options as to how she can approach the scenario: “Perfect Crime”, “Call Police”, and “Drive Away”. The movie ends up presenting these options in order, offering three ways in which the events of Barbara’s choices could play out. This premise is what the film hinges on, becoming an interesting lens with which to view the characters and story — at least initially.

Sew Torn Is A Movie About The Threads Of Fate, Weaving Different Narratives With The Same Premise

The Movie Crafts A Creative Storyline Across Its Three Possibilities

The most important element about Sew Torn is that it is not a time travel movie. Instead, the film presents three wholly separate scenarios with different, ᴅᴇᴀᴅly outcomes as Barbara becomes involved in the crime she’s come across. It’s not a secret that her decisions are going to lead to negative consequences; the movie illustrates this not just in the opening scene, but directly before her first choice plays out. While it makes the outcome of each timeline known before the story starts, it doesn’t detract much from the interesting way fate plays out.

The best part of all three scenarios is how Barbara is characterized consistently throughout, with the decisions she makes feeling like it’s in-character for her. For instance, there’s one constant in every timeline that is sensible for her character, something that made every new choice feel realistic. This is aided by Connolly’s performance, as she stands out among a sea of other quirky characters who have their own parts to play. They ebb and flow into the stories as needed, making for some interesting and comical interactions depending on the timeline.

However, it’s not just Barbara’s characterization that stands out: she also makes creative contraptions with her sewing materials depending on the scenarios she finds herself in. This leads to some highly memorable timelines, with the crime comedy movie playing into her skills with various degrees of humor. While this leads to some out-of-the-box scenes that are occasionally goofy compared to some of the more serious scenarios, they offer a level of uniquely fun idenтιтy to the film. These are probably the standout aspects of the movie, differentiating it from other stories in media with branching paths.

Despite Its Creative Presentation, Sew Torn Weaves Some Threads Better Than Others

The Movie’s Scenarios Evoke Apathy After A Little While

Unfortunately, Sew Torn‘s biggest negative quality comes from the knowledge that every scenario is going to end with Barbara’s life in danger. While the movie could have directly informed the audience of the timeline’s outcomes while still making events intriguing, around halfway through the film, it retreats to a place of apathy. This is particularly the case with some stories falling into very routine clichés. While these timelines contain stellar performances from stars like Calum Worthy and John Lynch, their appearances aren’t enough to strengthen the writing of each plot as they unfold.

This made the latter half of the movie feel dull, despite the attempts at making characters that had been two-dimensional up to that point more interesting. It’s neat to see how many ideas carry over into various ways events can play out, but it ultimately felt nullified by an inevitability that wasn’t staved off with much memorable creativity, save for Barbara’s use of sewing in ludicrously comedic ways. Luckily, it’s still admirable the film plays its premise straight instead of becoming a typical time loop movie or falling into any trappings that would mess with its unique ideas.

Despite a narrative that feels duller the more it drags on, Sew Torn still presents some interesting ideas and scenarios that make the movie’s multi-pronged narrative a unique experience. There’s plenty of off-beat comedy and tense sequences to be entertained by, especially thanks to Connolly stealing the show. Even so, the film ends up being a mixed bag depending on the story being followed, with the threads starting to tear apart as it goes on, until the plot starts wearing thin.

Sew Torn arrives in theaters on May 9.