Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare Theatrical Release Extended After 70% Audience RT Success

Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare‘s theatrical release has been extended after debuting with a 70% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes. Written and directed by Scott Jeffrey, the third film in the Twisted Childhood Universe follows Wendy Darling on a daring mission to save her brother from a sinister Peter Pan, who plans to take him to Neverland, while meeting a twisted Tinkerbell addicted to what she believes is fairy dust. Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare‘s cast includes Martin Portlock, Megan Placito, Kit Green, Peter DeSouza-Feighoney, Charity Kase, Teresa Banham, Campbell Wallace, Nicholas Woodeson, Kierston Wareing, and Olumide Olorunfemi.

Now, Jagged Edge Productions and ITN Studios have announced that Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare is extending its theatrical run across 75 different locations, including New York City, Universal City, California, Tampa, Florida, and more. The movie will now remain in theaters until January 23. Tickets are available online through Iconic Events Releasing or participating theaters.

What Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare’s Theatrical Extension Means For The Movie

Audiences Are Enjoying It

The extension of Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare‘s theatrical release suggests there is strong audience enthusiasm for the horror film. The film was originally released in limited theaters for three days from January 13–15 and, though box office numbers aren’t available, it had to have performed well for the studio to justify extending it. Audiences are seemingly enjoying the horror movie, evidenced by its 70% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes from 50+ verified ratings. While not an eye-popping number, it’s an increase from the TCU’s first film, Winnie-the-Pooh: Blood and Honey (49%), but not its sequel’s 73%.

While audiences seem to be enjoying the third TCU film, the same can’t exactly be said for critics. Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare reviews paint it as a divisive horror film, with some praising its dark creativity and disturbing visuals, while others criticize its lack of fun, weak character development, and predictable horror tropes. Some critics call it a fresh, twisted take on the childhood classic, while others see it as mean-spirited and uninspired. While its brutal kills and eerie premise impress some, its execution leaves many unimpressed, resulting in a 43% Rotten Tomatoes score from critics.

Our Take Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare’s Theatrical Extension

The TCU Has Seen Box Office Success

No matter what one thinks of the TCU, and there has certainly been a range of opinions regarding its reimagination of classic children’s characters as murderous villains, it’s difficult to deny that the movies have seen box office success with shoestring budgets and limited theatrical releases. Winnie-the-Pooh: Blood and Honey, despite its terrible 3% RT score, made $7.7 million at the box office on a $100,000 budget, and the sequel, with a much improved 47% RT score, made $7.6 million on a $500,000 budget. Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare is just the latest example of the TCU’s box office success.

Source: Jagged Edge Productions/ITN Studios

Related Posts

Melissa Barrera Sets Next Horror Movie Return With Unconventional Creature Feature

Melissa Barrera Sets Next Horror Movie Return With Unconventional Creature Feature

Modern scream queen Melissa Barrera has secured her next horror role, which should intrigue die-hard fans of the genre. The Scream, Abigail, and In the Heights star…

Warner Bros. Is Officially For Sale

Warner Bros. Is Officially For Sale

Following previous mergers and restructuring, Warner Bros. Discovery is up for sale. Reports about the mᴀssive Hollywood studio being acquired have been appearing over the last few…

Fast & Furious 11’s Problems “Solved” In New Vin Diesel Update

Fast & Furious 11’s Problems “Solved” In New Vin Diesel Update

After months of concerns that the planned final installment in the franchise would be axed altogether, Fast & Furious 11 looks to finally be on track. The…

Colleen Hoover’s New Movie Revealed In Reminders Of Him Trailer

Colleen Hoover’s New Movie Revealed In Reminders Of Him Trailer

The first trailer for Reminders of Him has been released. The film is an adaptation of the Colleen Hoover novel of the same name. The author’s books…

Avatar: Fire & Ash Could Be Huge For 2026’s Biggest Blockbusters

Avatar: Fire & Ash Could Be Huge For 2026’s Biggest Blockbusters

Avatar: Fire and Ash is positioned to end 2025 with a bang. James Cameron’s third entry in the Pandora-set, Na’vi-focused sci-fi franchise looks like it could be…

Overlooked Post-Apocalyptic Thriller That Made Only 6,595 Is No. 1 On Hulu

Overlooked Post-Apocalyptic Thriller That Made Only $776,595 Is No. 1 On Hulu

Hulu‘s top-streaming movie is a post-apocalyptic thriller that only made $776,595 at the box office. Even though Hulu is counting down the days until the app shuts…