Luna Is Great, But The Harry Potter Movies Should Have Cut Her From This One Scene

There is an essential scene in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince that sees Harry Potter bonding with another character, but the Harry Potter movie changes who this character is. In Half-Blood Prince, Harry spends much of the film trying to discover who the mysterious Half-Blood Prince is while also realizing that Lord Voldemort is raising his Death Eater army for an eventual attack launched against Hogwarts and the Wizarding World.

This led to Harry seeing Draco in a suspicious meeting on the Hogwarts Express. Harry used his Invisibility Cloak to sneak up on Draco and his family, but he wasn’t sneaky enough. Draco realized Harry was there and launched an attack when only he and Harry were left on the Hogwarts Express. Draco cast the Petrificus Totalus spell, which bound Harry, effectively paralyzing him.

He then threw the invisibility cloak over him to leave him there, with no one knowing about it. Luckily, someone found Harry and saved him. With that said, the book and movie changed who his savior was.

The Movie Swapped Tonks For Luna In The Hogwarts Express Scene

Nymphadora Tonks Found Harry Potter In The Books

Evanna Lynch as Luna Lovegood lifting her glᴀsses in Harry Potter.

In Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, Harry thought Draco Malfoy had become a Death Eater like his father. He begins to follow Draco on the Hogwarts Express and eavesdrop on his conversations with his family and other Death Eaters. However, when Draco realized Harry was under the invisibility cloak, he attacked, broke Harry’s nose, and hit him with the Petrificus Totalus spell.

He left Harry under the cloak and departed the train, leaving it looking like no one would find Harry. However, Luna Lovegood found him thanks to the spectrespecs she wore.

This isn’t what happened in the book, where Nymphadora Tonks finds Harry. Instead of Luna, which was used as a quirky and fun scene with her making funny comments as she saved him, the scene in the books was a lot more serious. Instead of a light-hearted moment with the fun Luna, it was a time for Harry to share with Tonks, who had become deeply depressed after her cousin Sirius died and her lover, Remus Lupin, rejected her.

In the book, Nymphadora Tonks is there to watch after the kids.

In the scene, she rescues him, heals his broken nose, and helps send him back to Hogwarts. However, the scene happens differently from the movie. In the film, Luna finds Harry there thanks to her glᴀsses. However, in the book, Nymphadora Tonks is there to watch after the kids, and she realizes Harry has never gotten off the train and goes to find him. As she takes Harry back to school, the two have time to connect, and he realizes how much pain Tonks is in at that time in her life.

Changing This Scene Takes Away An Important Moment For Tonks

Nymphadora Tonks Deserved Better In The Harry Potter Franchise

Remis Lupin & Nymphadora Tonks in Harry Potter

Nymphadora Tonks had a powerful storyline in the Harry Potter novels. She was a wizard struggling to come into her own, and she doubted her magic skills. She watched her cousin, Sirius Black, die in the previous book while she battled Bellatrix, making her feel guilty over his death.

She also had Remus Lupin reject her and take dangerous missions because he thought his status as a werewolf with no wealth wasn’t good enough for her. She was in a deep state of depression when she found and saved Harry Potter.

Throughout the films, Nymphadora Tonks’s storyline was almost eliminated. Her relationship with Remus Lupin was an essential part of the books but glossed over in the films, which hurt the final movie. When Remus and Tonks die in the Battle of Hogwarts, the movie shows them side by side, and it is supposed to hit hard. However, the Harry Potter franchise never allowed fans to care enough about her for their deaths to matter. Changes like the Hogwarts Express scene were a big part of that.

With the upcoming Harry Potter series on HBO Max, there will be much more time to devote to other characters and storylines. This means people like Nymphadora Tonks can see their stories told in greater detail. If the series adds back in things like Tonks and Harry bonding after the attack, it could go a long way toward making her eventual death mean so much more for fans.

Related Posts

Box Office: Jurᴀssic World Rebirth Stomps Past Projections With Record-Breaking Debut

Box Office: Jurᴀssic World Rebirth Stomps Past Projections With Record-Breaking Debut

Jurᴀssic World Rebirth has stomped past its original projections during its opening weekend. The new movie, which is the seventh installment in the Jurᴀssic franchise, was directed…

F1 The Movie Box Office Outgrossing More Than 3 Dozen Other Brad Pitt Movies With New Milestone

F1 The Movie Box Office Outgrossing More Than 3 Dozen Other Brad Pitt Movies With New Milestone

F1 The Movie is racing to become one of Brad Pitt’s highest-grossing movies ever. The new movie, which was directed by Top Gun: Maverick‘s Joseph Kosinski, stars…

The Fantastic Four: First Steps Comic Tie-In Confirms Paul Walter Hauser’s Mystery Marvel Role

The Fantastic Four: First Steps Comic Tie-In Confirms Paul Walter Hauser’s Mystery Marvel Role

The Fantastic Four: First Steps comic tie-in finally reveals who Paul Walter Hauser will be playing in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Phase 6 is about to start…

How To Train Your Dragon Box Office Breaks Franchise’s 15-Year Record In Just One Month

How To Train Your Dragon Box Office Breaks Franchise’s 15-Year Record In Just One Month

How to Train Your Dragon has broken a major record for the franchise. The 2025 movie is a live-action remake of the 2010 animated movie of the…

Superman Star Nicholas Hoult Reveals He Consulted Smallville’s Michael Rosenbaum On Playing The DCU’s Lex Luthor

Ahead of Superman’s release, Nicholas Hoult revealed how previous Lex Luthor actor Michael Rosenbaum reacted to his casting as the iconic DC villain. The latter portrayed Lex…

“That Conflict Is Very Realistic”: Hazing Incident & Trial In Tom Cruise’s Iconic 3M Legal Movie Gets Perfect Score From Marine Corps Leader

“That Conflict Is Very Realistic”: Hazing Incident & Trial In Tom Cruise’s Iconic $243M Legal Movie Gets Perfect Score From Marine Corps Leader

Tom Cruise, often considered the last Hollywood movie star, has been an iconic presence in the industry since the ’80s, when he debuted in a couple of…