The cast of Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves was one of the highlights of the fantasy adventure, but the sequel may be better off making some drastic changes. The Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves cast features the likes of Chris Pine, Michelle Rodriguez, Regé-Jean Page, and Hugh Grant in its ensemble of colorful characters to help bring the beloved game to life in movie form. These actors shared wonderful chemistry that elevated the film’s humor as well as the surprising emotional moments.

The success of the cast helped the movie become a surprise critical success with 91% on Rotten Tomatoes. While the film was not as big at the box office as hoped for, there are still a lot of fans who want to see a Dungeons & Dragons sequel happen. However, as much as Pine and company were instrumental to the charm of the first movie, the sequel could work better if it tells a new story focused on new characters and features an entirely new cast.

New Characters Would Allow Fans To See Different D&D Classes

Dungeons & Dragons Presents An Expansive Universe To Explore

Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves‘ ending sees the main heroes all surviving their ordeal, meaning it is entirely possible to have them return in a new movie. However, simply having the same characters return for a sequel would be ignoring one of the biggest advantages of adapting a franchise like Dungeons & Dragons. With such a big world and so many different classes of characters within Dungeons & Dragons, it would be a shame not to explore as many as possible.

While a Dungeons & Dragons sequel could see the main characters returning once again and having them face off with another Dungeons & Dragons villain, that would feel so limiting for such an expansive universe to explore. The characters of the first movie worked so well, but there is nothing stopping the filmmakers from having as much success with a new group of heroes who also represent new areas of the lore.

While it is possible the sequel could just add new characters, like making a wizard or ranger part of the hero team, in order for the sequel to really embrace the possibilities of the universe, it can’t repeat itself. Honor Among Thieves had a lot of fun ᴀssembling this crew for what was essentially a fantasy heist adventure. That was a unique and entertaining approach, but it doesn’t need to be done again. These new characters can present a new storytelling avenue to expand on the universe and keep things fresh.

A D&D Sequel Would Likely Keep The Original Cast

It Is Rare For A Sequel To Have No Returning Characters

A new cast for the Dungeons & Dragons sequel is a great way to approach continuing the franchise, but if the sequel is going to happen, fans should expect to see the original cast return. While some movie franchises constantly change cast members, like Batman and James Bond, it is rare for a franchise to take a complete anthology storytelling approach in creating an entirely new story and cast of characters for each new installment.

Regardless of whether or not it is a wise move, it is a risk, and a Dungeons & Dragons sequel is likely not going to take too many risks. The first movie was not a financial success, which is why the sequel is still not a sure thing. With the movie’s strong word of mouth and success on streaming, the studio will likely want to ensure the sequel capitalizes on what people liked about the first movie, and the cast is an easy answer in that regard.

Fans will be happy to see the same cast return, and it is almost certain that a sequel would introduce new classes to join the established characters. There is also the upcoming Dungeons & Dragons TV show that will give fans a chance to see the expanded universe of the game brought to life. It is unlikely the movie cast will return for the show, so it gives the chance to tell a completely new story with new characters. However, a new cast for the sequel of Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves could be what helps the franchise grow.