If This Moment In The Godfather Hadn’t Happened, Michael Corleone Never Would Have Been Vito’s Successor

By the end of The Godfather, Michael Corleone has become cold-hearted enough to take his father’s place as the head of the family, but if one storyline had turned out differently, that wouldn’t have happened. The Godfather chronicles the dual stories of a seasoned mob boss reaching the end of his life and choosing a successor, and his only wayward son getting drawn into a life of crime. Michael was supposed to be the first Corleone to lead a legitimate life, but he ended up being the only suitable candidate to replace his dad.

At the beginning of the movie, Michael is the good son — a noble war veteran with clean hands — but, by the end of it, Michael has become even more ruthless than Vito. Michael’s journey to the dark side begins when he ᴀssᴀssinates a police captain and ends when he has all his gangland rivals whacked while he’s at his nephew’s baptism. But Michael wouldn’t have become cruel and uncaring enough to succeed Vito as the don at the end of The Godfather if a key subplot had turned out differently.

Michael Wouldn’t Have Become The Godfather If Apollonia Had Lived

Michael Truly Loved Apollonia In A Way He Doesn’t Really Love Kay

After killing Captain McCluskey, Michael goes to Sicily to hide out until the heat dies down and he can return to America. There, he meets and falls for a local woman named Apollonia. Michael marries Apollonia, but sadly, in their early days of marital bliss, his new bride is killed in a car bomb meant for him. If this storyline had shaken out a little differently and Apollonia hadn’t died, then Michael wouldn’t have been able to succeed his father as the don.

If Apollonia had lived, Michael wouldn’t have been ruthless or determined enough to take over from Vito, because he was weakened by his love for her.

Michael truly loved Apollonia in a way he doesn’t really love Kay. Michael and Apollonia were happy together as newlyweds, and her untimely death was what pushed Michael toward becoming the cold-blooded monster he needed to be to become a successful mob boss. If Apollonia had lived, Michael wouldn’t have been ruthless or determined enough to take over from Vito, because he was weakened by his love for her. When he’s with Kay, he can make the business his top priority.

The Godfather’s Sicily Scenes Slow Down The Movie, But They’re An Important Part Of Michael’s Arc

It’s A Major Turning Point In Michael’s Journey


Michael in Sicily in The Godfather

The Godfather’s Sicily scenes are arguably the most boring section of the movie, because they take you out of the action just as it was getting exciting. But it’s a crucial juncture in Michael’s character arc. He gets a better understanding of the role of a don from his time with Don Tommasino. Michael previously thought the notion of one person ruling over an entire neighborhood was at odds with the freedom and optimism of the American dream. But after spending some time in Sicily, he sees that a don can play a positive role in the community.

Related Posts

A Minecraft Movie’s Earlier Villain Plan Was Much Bigger Than Malgosha, & I’m Bummed They Changed It

A Minecraft Movie’s Earlier Villain Plan Was Much Bigger Than Malgosha, & I’m Bummed They Changed It

A Minecraft Movie may not have quite lived up to every viewer’s expectations, but there are still aspects of this messy story to be enjoyed. The chemistry…

A Lot Of Movie Characters Are Annoying, But I’d Love To Be Real-Life Friends With These 8

A Lot Of Movie Characters Are Annoying, But I’d Love To Be Real-Life Friends With These 8

Movie characters wouldn’t always make for great real-life friends, but a few standout as invaluable friends that anyone would be lucky to have. Even the greatest movie…

Ryan Gosling’s Star Wars Movie, Starfighter, Can Be The Perfect Replacement For One Part Of The Mandalorian

Ryan Gosling’s Star Wars Movie, Starfighter, Can Be The Perfect Replacement For One Part Of The Mandalorian

Ryan Gosling’s upcoming Star Wars movie, Star Wars: Starfighter, could re-use one major detail from The Mandalorian franchise. Announced at Star Wars Celebration 2025, Shawn Levy’s Star…

“We’re Going To Push For Everything”: Knives Out 3 Release Window Revealed As Wake Up ᴅᴇᴀᴅ Man Director Hopes For Theater Plan

“We’re Going To Push For Everything”: Knives Out 3 Release Window Revealed As Wake Up ᴅᴇᴀᴅ Man Director Hopes For Theater Plan

Knives Out franchise creator Rian Johnson addresses his theater hopes and the release window for Wake Up ᴅᴇᴀᴅ Man. Netflix will once again see the whodunit franchise…

Every ᴀssᴀssin In The Accountant Movies, Ranked

Every ᴀssᴀssin In The Accountant Movies, Ranked

The Accountant franchise has become even more expansive following the release of The Accountant 2, which introduces several new characters that pose serious threats to Christian Wolff…

“It Felt Like The Missing Puzzle Piece!” Kerry Washington Praises Omar Sy’s Role In Shadow Force

“It Felt Like The Missing Puzzle Piece!” Kerry Washington Praises Omar Sy’s Role In Shadow Force

Kerry Washington and Omar Sy have joined forces as a couple of AWOL agents in Shadow Force. The two tenured thespians portray Kyrah and Isaac, a married…