Five Nights At Freddy’s 2 Writer & Creator Listened To Fan Concerns When Crafting Sequel, Star Reveals

Five Nights at Freddy’s 2

gets a new tease from star Matthew Lillard, who reveals that screenwriter Scott Cawthon listened to fan concerns when writing the sequel. Based on Cawthon’s video game franchise of the same name, the first Five Nights at Freddy’s hit theaters in 2023, with Lillard starring as villain William Afton, alongside other cast members Josh Hutcherson and Elizabeth Lail. Despite poor reviews, the film was a major hit for Blumhouse, and Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 is now confirmed to be arriving later this year with original movie director Emma Tammi back at the helm.

During a recent interview with ComingSoon.net, Lillard speaks briefly about Five Nights at Freddy’s 2, teasing that learnings from the first movie have been incorporated into the second. The actor hints that audiences could be in for more scares and potentially more action, though he doesn’t confirm any specifics. Check out his comment below:

But I do think that the movie learned first time around, I think Scott, as a primary storyteller, listened to the audience. [It’s] what he does best. He knows that community so well. And I think that he’s responded with a script that… maybe it has more jump scares. Maybe it’s a little more action-packed. I don’t know. I’m not here to say “yes it is”, or “no it’s not.”

What This Means For Five Nights At Freddy’s 2

The First Movie’s Poor Reviews Explained

Five Nights at Freddy’s was a major win for Blumhouse. Made on an estimated budget of $20 million, the film grossed $291 million worldwide, making it the highest-grossing movie ever for the company. This commercial success didn’t accompany critical success, however, and the film has only a 32% score on Rotten Tomatoes. In her Five Nights at Freddy’s review for ScreenRant, Mae Abdulbaki awards the movie a lackluster five out 10, taking issue with the simple story and lack of any real scares:

I can’t compare the film to the game because I haven’t played it, but the adaptation is fairly generic and very light on the horror. That said, Five Nights at Freddy’s isn’t a complete dud, and it’s quite enjoyable and interesting when it gets going.

Lillard’s comment, then, could suggest that, after the Five Nights at Freddy’s ending, the sequel will be upping the ante with its scares. The follow-up could still have its hands tied somewhat, however, as it will likely carry a PG-13 rating like its predecessor. Without a PG-13 rating, the first Five Nights at Freddy’s probably would not have performed as well at the box office, and the sequel won’t be looking to make any major changes in this regard. The sequel could, however, sport a larger budget, allowing for a higher production value, which could enhance the scares and action.

Our Take On Lillard’s Five Nights At Freddy’s 2 Tease

The Sequel Could Still Be Scary With A PG-13


Matthew Lillard smiling as William Afton in Five Nights at Freddy's

It’s worth noting that, though Five Nights at Freddy’s only has a 32% critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes, the audience-driven Popcornmeter score is much higher at 86%. Combined with the box office performance, it’s hard to label the film as anything but a win, but that doesn’t mean there isn’t room for improvement. An R-rated take on the game probably isn’t on the cards, meaning those hoping for more blood and disturbing terror will likely be disappointed, but the sequel could still push some boundaries in fun ways.

Plenty of horror movies have succeeded and still been scary with a PG-13 rating, and an increased focus on building up to these moments in the script could definitely improve the sequel. A higher production value in terms of the animatronics themselves could also help. It remains to be seen if Five Nights at Freddy’s 2 will be an improvement over the first critically, but audiences can seemingly expect some upgrades from the first installment.

Well-received PG-13 horror movies include Drag Me To Hell (2009), Split (2016), A Quiet Place (2018), and The Boogeyman (2023).

Source: ComingSoon.net

Related Posts

Melissa Barrera Sets Next Horror Movie Return With Unconventional Creature Feature

Melissa Barrera Sets Next Horror Movie Return With Unconventional Creature Feature

Modern scream queen Melissa Barrera has secured her next horror role, which should intrigue die-hard fans of the genre. The Scream, Abigail, and In the Heights star…

Warner Bros. Is Officially For Sale

Warner Bros. Is Officially For Sale

Following previous mergers and restructuring, Warner Bros. Discovery is up for sale. Reports about the mᴀssive Hollywood studio being acquired have been appearing over the last few…

Fast & Furious 11’s Problems “Solved” In New Vin Diesel Update

Fast & Furious 11’s Problems “Solved” In New Vin Diesel Update

After months of concerns that the planned final installment in the franchise would be axed altogether, Fast & Furious 11 looks to finally be on track. The…

Colleen Hoover’s New Movie Revealed In Reminders Of Him Trailer

Colleen Hoover’s New Movie Revealed In Reminders Of Him Trailer

The first trailer for Reminders of Him has been released. The film is an adaptation of the Colleen Hoover novel of the same name. The author’s books…

Avatar: Fire & Ash Could Be Huge For 2026’s Biggest Blockbusters

Avatar: Fire & Ash Could Be Huge For 2026’s Biggest Blockbusters

Avatar: Fire and Ash is positioned to end 2025 with a bang. James Cameron’s third entry in the Pandora-set, Na’vi-focused sci-fi franchise looks like it could be…

Overlooked Post-Apocalyptic Thriller That Made Only 6,595 Is No. 1 On Hulu

Overlooked Post-Apocalyptic Thriller That Made Only $776,595 Is No. 1 On Hulu

Hulu‘s top-streaming movie is a post-apocalyptic thriller that only made $776,595 at the box office. Even though Hulu is counting down the days until the app shuts…