Twilight’s TV Remake Can Fix A Breaking Dawn Problem Thanks To 1 Book Moment

The upcoming Twilight animated TV series has the chance to fix some of The Twilight Saga’s mistakes, and if it stays true to one Midnight Sun moment, it will fix a Breaking Dawn mistake. The Twilight Saga ended in 2012 with the release of Breaking Dawn – Part 2, and though the movie series had been in decline for years, it gave fans the ending they had been waiting for. However, it wasn’t safe from criticism from both fans and critics, especially when it came to the character of Renesmee.

The Twilight books and movies continue to have a solid fanbase, and now, after over a decade since the Twilight Saga ended, the world of Bella and Edward will expand with a TV show – an animated one. The concept for the Twilight animated TV show is to tell the events of the first movie, but with a twist. Instead of adapting the Twilight novel, the animated show will adapt Midnight Sun, the retelling of the first book, but from Edward’s perspective. Thanks to this, if it keeps one key book moment, the Twilight TV show could fix a big Breaking Dawn mistake.

Twilight TV Series Has To Include The Denali Clan Thanks To 1 Key Midnight Sun Moment

Midnight Sun Explains Where Edward Went In Twilight

Edward and Bella’s relationship has a rough start in Twilight. On the first day of school, Bella sits next to Edward during biology class, but he’s visibly repulsed by her. The audience later learns that Bella’s scent is too strong and irresistible for Edward, who struggles to maintain his posture as a “vegetarian” vampire around Bella. Midnight Sun explores what goes through Edward’s mind at those moments, and he goes as far as considering killing Bella and their classmates so he wouldn’t leave any witnesses.

Disturbed by his own thoughts, Edward decides to leave Forks for a week, but Twilight never explains where he goes. Midnight Sun reveals that Edward goes into hiding at the Denali National Park in Alaska with the Denali clan. This group is so close to the Cullens that they consider each other cousins, and the bond is such that one of the Denali members, Tanya, has feelings for Edward. Tanya even believes that Edward arrives to return her feelings, but she eventually understands that Edward isn’t for her.

In the movies, the Denali clan isn’t properly introduced until Breaking Dawn, and their presence is too weird and forgettable.

It’s Tanya who convinces Edward to return to Forks and face his problems, and so he does. With the Twilight TV remake adapting Midnight Sun, it should include this moment in Edward and Bella’s story. In the movies, the Denali clan isn’t properly introduced until Breaking Dawn, and their presence is too weird and forgettable. However, being introduced when Edward goes into hiding would make their future appearances a lot smoother and more believable.

The Denali Clan Were Unfairly Underdeveloped In Breaking Dawn

Breaking Dawn Awkwardly Introduced The Denali Clan


Twilight Breaking Dawn 2 the Denali coven

As mentioned above, in the Twilight movie series the Denali coven is officially introduced in Breaking Dawn. The Denalis attend Edward and Bella’s wedding, where Irina is disgusted by the presence of werewolves. It’s Irina who brings conflict in both Breaking Dawn movies as she returns to visit the Cullens and sees a (now transformed) Bella hunting with Jacob and Renesmee, who Irina mistakes for an immortal child. As such, Irina notifies the Volturi, who later confront the Cullens and their allies about Renesmee.

While this could have been exciting, the truth is that both Breaking Dawn movies were overpacked with characters, and the Denalis’ appearance felt out of the blue. Even their presence in Breaking Dawn – Part 2, when the Cullens are about to face the Volturi, feels strange, as there’s no time to properly develop the characters. This could change in the Twilight TV show if the Denalis are introduced in the first season, which would make their potential future appearances on the show a lot smoother.

Related Posts

If I Were Starting Supernatural In 2025, I Wouldn’t Bother Watching These 8 Season 1 Episodes

If I Were Starting Supernatural In 2025, I Wouldn’t Bother Watching These 8 Season 1 Episodes

Supernatural is America’s longest-running live-action fantasy show, and one of its best in many ways, but some season 1 episodes could be skipped in order to get…

Stranger Things Season 5 Must Fix A Tragic Season 4 Mistake That Could Ruin The Show’s Ending

Stranger Things Season 5 Must Fix A Tragic Season 4 Mistake That Could Ruin The Show’s Ending

There’s a lot of pressure on Stranger Things season 5 to succeed, thanks to its reputation and long hiatus, but the final episodes can get off to…

Elsa Dutton Proves A Commonly-Held Belief About The Dutton Family In 1883 Is A Total Misconception, And It Changes Yellowstone’s Ending

Elsa Dutton Proves A Commonly-Held Belief About The Dutton Family In 1883 Is A Total Misconception, And It Changes Yellowstone’s Ending

There’s a common misconception about 1883’s Dutton family, and Elsa Dutton (Isabel May) proves that it’s not true. Elsa is the eldest child of James (Tim McGraw)…

American Primeval Is The Closest Thing Netflix Has Offered To A Replacement For HBO’s Classic Western Series

American Primeval Is The Closest Thing Netflix Has Offered To A Replacement For HBO’s Classic Western Series

Warning: Contains SPOILERS for American Primeval. The Western genre, with its iconic imagery and themes, has been a staple of American storytelling for generations, and American Primeval…

Power Rangers’ New Show Can Easily Avoid The Failed 2017 Reboot’s Biggest Mistake

Power Rangers’ New Show Can Easily Avoid The Failed 2017 Reboot’s Biggest Mistake

The 2017 Power Rangers movie did a lot of things right, but it also made one big mistake that I hope the new live-action series will avoid….

4 Perfect James Bond Prospects All Broke Big In The Same TV Show 18 Years Ago

4 Perfect James Bond Prospects All Broke Big In The Same TV Show 18 Years Ago

Four actors, who are considered great prospects for the next James Bond role, surprisingly broke big in the same 18-year-old TV show. It has been a while…