Eiza González’s New Sci-Fi Movie Copies Ridley Scott’s Controversial $403 Million Alien Prequel

The following contains spoilers for Ash, now playing in theatersAsh does a lot of the same things that Ridley Scott attempted in his contentious $403 million Alien prequel, Prometheus. Directed by Flying Lotus, Ash is a horror/sci-fi hybrid that focuses on Eiza González’s Riya, one of the only apparent survivors of a mysterious event at a terraforming station in deep space. Much of the film is carried by Riya, who struggles to regain her full memories of the event while also wrestling with whether to trust Ash‘s other main character Brion, another survivor who is committed to them escaping the planet with their lives.

Eiza González leads the Ash cast with grace, keeping Riya compelling even as her mysterious past and guily memories resurface. The ending of Ash cements Riya as a fun modern heir to the archetype codified by Ellen Ripley in Alien. That connection between Ash and Alien does feel purposeful, especially when one considers all the ways that Ash is connected on a story level with Prometheus, up to having very similar final endings. While Ash feels inspired by many sci-fi movies, the thematic connections with Prometheus are hard to ignore.

Ash’s Ending For Eiza González’s Riya Is Similar To Shaw’s Ending In Prometheus

Riya And Shaw Go Through Very Similar Traumas

The ending of Ash has some thematic similarities to Ridley Scott’s Prometheus, further hammering home the spiritual connection between Ash and previous generations of sci-fi filmmaking. Both Ash and Prometheus build off the horror of an alien parasite infecting someone and transforming them. That’s always been at the core of the Alien franchise, with Prometheus taking it further than ever by having Shaw perform an emergency C-section on herself to get rid of the alien. Ash does something similar, with Riya using a similar mechanical device to extract the alien parasite from her head.

Both characters survive encounters with corrupted crew members and alien menace, surviving to the end of the film and seemingly escaping the narrative. However, both Flying Lotus and Ridley Scott subvert this triumphant turn. In Ash, it’s revealed the satellite Riya is heading towards is already infected with more of the alien life form. Prometheus ends on an ambiguous note by having Shaw alongside the dangerous David. This leads to Shaw’s off-screen death and direction, as revealed in Alien: Covenant. Both films approach similar themes and even end in similar ways.

Ash Feels A Lot Like An Alien Movie, Even If It Isn’t

Ash Shares A Lot Of Visual Elements And Tonal Aspects With The Alien Franchise


Eiza González holding a knife as Riya in Ash

On the whole, Ash feels deliberately modeled after Alien franchise. Ash takes place on an isolated facility in deep-space, with a small crew bedeviled, corrupted, and killed off by an alien life form that can turn them against one another. This seemingly “perfect” alien in Ash and the Alien films wants to ᴀssimilate any species it encounters, including humanity. Both films have grim views on humanity’s flaws and the overconfidence of scientists in messing with the unknown. Both movies also use a “gritty” approach to sci-fi to emphasize the bleaker edges of the story.

Even as Ash takes clear inspiration from films like Prometheus and Alien, the Eiza González-led sci-fi feels like a uniquely human response to that genre.

Riya has some connections to Shaw from Prometheus, the last surviving scientist in the crew who is forced to put down her lover after he’s transformed into a monster. What makes Ash stand out from the other films that have taken clear inspiration from the Alien movies is the way it crystallized the human core of the character. Riya’s horror and grief propels the film in a way the sometimes emotionally cold Alien films don’t. Even as Ash takes clear inspiration from films like Prometheus and Alien, the Eiza González-led sci-fi feels like a uniquely human response to that genre.

Related Posts

The Rings Of Power Can Finally Answer One Huge Nazgûl Question (& It’s Not The One You’re Thinking Of)

The Rings Of Power Can Finally Answer One Huge Nazgûl Question (& It’s Not The One You’re Thinking Of)

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power may answer questions about the Ringwraiths that Lord of the Rings fans have had for years. The Amazon…

How To Watch The Predator Movies In Order

How To Watch The Predator Movies In Order

The Predator franchise features some outright classics and a few lesser outings, but it can be tough for the uninitiated to work out the chronological and release…

I Can’t Believe Marvel Is Already Wasting 2 Of The 3 Black Widow Replacements It Set Up For The MCU

I Can’t Believe Marvel Is Already Wasting 2 Of The 3 Black Widow Replacements It Set Up For The MCU

Out of the three potential Black Widow replacements that the MCU has set up so far, two of them are seemingly already going to waste. Scarlett Johansson’s…

Legend of Zelda Live Action: Release Date, Director & Everything We Know

Legend of Zelda Live Action: Release Date, Director & Everything We Know

A live-action film adaptation of The Legend of Zelda has been announced, and updates are flooding in regarding Nintendo’s upcoming cinematic adventure. The video game series first…

“It’s A Bold Choice”: Sonic 3’s Dual Jim Carrey Robotnik Montages Gets Glowing Review From VFX Artists

“It’s A Bold Choice”: Sonic 3’s Dual Jim Carrey Robotnik Montages Gets Glowing Review From VFX Artists

The painstaking visual effects used to bring Jim Carrey’s dual performance in Sonic the Hedgehog 3 receives glowing praise as the VFX experts at Corridor Crew dive…

Only One Main Sonic The Hedgehog Character Hasn’t Had Their Own Movie & It Breaks My Heart To Say It

Only One Main Sonic The Hedgehog Character Hasn’t Had Their Own Movie & It Breaks My Heart To Say It

Of all the video game characters featured in the Sonic the Hedgehog live-action series, only one of them has not been the focus of their own movie….