Russo Bros. Address Convincing Robert Downey Jr. To Play Iron Man As An Antagonist In Captain America: Civil War

Once upon a time, Captain America: Civil War was just an idea in Joe and Anthony Russo’s collective think tank. The 2016 film sees the Avengers divided into factions, with Captain America/Steve Rogers (Chris Evans) opposing legislation to regulate the heroes’ actions and Iron Man/Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr.) supporting it. Matters are more complicated when Steve is forced to defend his lifelong best friend Bucky Barnes/the Winter Soldier (Sebastian Stan), who was brainwashed into murdering many innocent people, including Tony’s parents.

Interestingly, the brothers recently revealed the humorous story behind how they managed to get approval for as bold an idea as pitting the two biggest faces of the MCU against one another. In a new profile from The Hollywood Reporter, the Russos explained that they had two major hurdles in getting the pitch off of the ground.

Naturally, they had to convince MCU architect Kevin Feige. However, Anthony explained how the Marvel Studios boss responded: “We pitched Kevin on the idea and Kevin goes, ‘All right, I buy it. Now you guys got to go get Downey.’ And I was like, ‘What do you mean we got to go get Downey? Aren’t you coming?’ And he didn’t.

Joe then told the story of how they visited Downey to woo him as a star for their next film. The Iron Man star “was sitting on a chaise lounge, splayed out like a king, on the roof of his office in Venice,” when the brothers “showed up [after they’d] been rehearsing this pitch.” He then pointed out the pressure of the situation: “You’re literally pitching the biggest movie star in the world to take his giant cash cow character and convert it into a villain.

Though Tony acts as an antagonist to Steve in Captain America: Civil War, he is not the primary villain of the film. Rather, Helmut Zemo (Daniel Brühl) is the main antagonist.

Anthony also noted that they were taking this big swing for a Captain America film, not even one where Iron Man would be the тιтle character. Joe called Captain America: Civil War “the pitch of [their] lives,” adding that the actor “liked the risk, to Robert’s credit, and that choice led the explosive upside to Infinity War and Endgame.”

What The Russo Brothers’ Story About Robert Downey Jr. Mean

Captain America: Civil War was a risky endeavor. After all, the MCU had established tensions between Captain America and Iron Man way back in The Avengers. However, clashing as coworkers is very different from fighting over potentially dangerous legislation or protecting the murderer of one’s parent. The repercussions of pitting the two franchise leads against one another would fundamentally, irreparably alter its trajectory.

It’s understandable that the Russos would be nervous to pitch a story that paints Iron Man as an antagonist for Captain America. If poorly executed, it could tarnish the reputations of both characters or turn fans off from the franchise. Moreover, the Civil War run in the comics is highly thought of, meaning the pressure is even more intense. Alternatively, that kind of risk may have been what made Downey accept the script.

Our Take On The Russo Brothers’ Story About Robert Downey Jr.


Iron Man stabbed with Captain America's shield in Captain America Civil War

While the film was a mᴀssive gamble on Marvel’s part, Captain America: Civil War went on to become one of the most successful and beloved entries in the MCU. Ironically, the most compelling part of the film was the debate between Captain America and Iron Man, as both had valid points with regard to the Avengers and to Bucky’s past crimes.

Additionally, the movie also brought Black Panther and Spider-Man into the MCU, which only made the excitement surrounding the film more strong. Captain America: Civil War was an incredibly ambitious film, between the new characters and the believable conflict between the MCU heroes. Clearly, Feige and Downey were right to trust the Russos.

Upcoming MCU Movies




  • Thunderbolts (2025) Official Poster

    Thunderbolts*

    Release Date

    May 2, 2025








  • 01593277_poster_w780.jpg

    The Fantastic Four: First Steps

    Release Date

    July 25, 2025








  • Avengers 5 Concept Poster

    Avengers: Doomsday (2026)









  • Spider-Man Homecoming Mondo Poster

    MCU Spider-Man 4

    Release Date

    July 24, 2026








  • Avengers: Secret Wars

    Release Date

    May 7, 2027





Related Posts

13 K-Pop Albums You Have To Listen To If You’ve Watched KPop Demon Hunters

13 K-Pop Albums You Have To Listen To If You’ve Watched KPop Demon Hunters

KPop Demon Hunters is one of Netflix’s latest animated movies, and it is one that has already leaped atop the charts as Netflix’s most streamed movie. As…

James Cameron’s Bn Franchise Future Is Exciting, But I Still Need A Real Sequel To His Sci-Fi Masterpiece

James Cameron’s $5Bn Franchise Future Is Exciting, But I Still Need A Real Sequel To His Sci-Fi Masterpiece

James Cameron is one of the most prolific sci-fi directors of all time. His films are unique in that they are both formative works in the sci-fi…

Jurᴀssic World Rebirth’s Rotten Tomatoes Score Highlights A Harsh Reality For The Bn Franchise

Jurᴀssic World Rebirth’s Rotten Tomatoes Score Highlights A Harsh Reality For The $6Bn Franchise

Jurᴀssic World Rebirth is another attempt at reviving the dinosaur franchise, but it comes with mixed results – especially where its reviews and Rotten Tomatoes score are…

Spider-Man: Far From Home’s Nick Fury Plot Twist Was Almost So Much Better Thanks To 1 Missed Peter Parker Story Change

Spider-Man: Far From Home’s Nick Fury Plot Twist Was Almost So Much Better Thanks To 1 Missed Peter Parker Story Change

Spider-Man: Far From Home offered a thrilling twist in its post-credits scene, but it could have been more much more impactful if Marvel hadn’t changed the original…

Mortal Kombat 2 Has Set Up One Dream Johnny Cage Fight After Divisive Changes To A Classic Character

Mortal Kombat 2 Has Set Up One Dream Johnny Cage Fight After Divisive Changes To A Classic Character

Now that he is finally making his debut in Mortal Kombat 2, Johnny Cage can fight a character who will return from the ᴅᴇᴀᴅ in the sequel….

Darth Maul’s New Show Could Connect 3 Star Wars Series In An Epic Way

Darth Maul’s New Show Could Connect 3 Star Wars Series In An Epic Way

Maul: Shadow Lord is on its way, but there’s one thing I desperately want to see in the show that’ll connect it to three different Star Wars…