John Lithgow Just Reminded Me Why He’ll Be A Great Dumbledore… Thanks To A New Horror Movie

The following contains spoilers for The Rule Of Jenny Pen, now playing in theatersJohn Lithgow’s performance in the horror film The Rule of Jenny Pen is quietly a great showcase of the skills that the actor will bring to his upcoming role of Albus Dumbledore in the Harry Potter TV show. John Lithgow has been a consistent presence in Hollywood for decades, showcasing a deep versatility over the years. He has been able to bring an unᴀssuming and realistic edge to everything from sitcom aliens to dramatic serial killers, earning Lithgow the respect of his peers and the admiration of generations of film and television fans.

One of his biggest roles ever is set to be in the upcoming television adaptation of the Harry Potter series, where John Lithgow will play Dumbledore. Before he becomes the Headmaster of Hogwarts though, his latest horror film highlights the sheer versatility Lithgow has as a performer and his ability to infuse even seemingly kooky character beats with a secondary layer of complexity or darkness. Here are the impressive traits Lithgow shows off in the terrifying The Rule of Jenny Pen and how they bode well for his Harry Potter performance.

John Lithgow’s Rule Of Jenny Pen Performance Is Great

John Lithgow’s Dave Crealy Is Bizarrely Funny But Still Uniquely Horrifying

John Lithgow’s disturbingly compelling performance in The Rule of Jenny Pen is fantastic and highlights the versatility he can bring to Dumbledore in the upcoming live-action Harry Potter TV show. Lithgow appears in the film as Dave Crealy, one of the patients at a remote ᴀssisted living facility for the elderly. Crealy is also the quiet despot of the center, who uses his knowledge of the facility and comparatively good health to abuse the other patients into subservient respect. Crealy is a cruel character who convinces the staff that he’s a kooky old man who needs his baby doll.

In reality, Crealy uses the doll as part of his tortuous treatment of the other patients. He’s silly and threatening at the same time, quickly able to shift from bizarre to horrifying and back again with ease. It’s a testament to Lithgow’s skills as an actor that Crealy remains such a threatening presence even after audiences have watched him force everyone else off the dance floor or panic after realizing he’s left evidence on one of his victims. That natural versatility will serve him well as Dumbledore.

What Lithgow’s Jenny Pen Role Can Tease About His Dumbledore

An Ability To Change Tenor And Tone With Ease Is Key To Dumbledore


John Lithgow with a giant baby face behind him in The Rule of Jenny Pen

On paper, Crealy and Dumbledore couldn’t be two more distinct characters. The former is a monstrous bully who targets others for the thrill of it, while the latter is a noble if flawed hero who becomes a vital mentor for generations of witches and wizards. However, John Lithgow’s performance as Crealy highlights some of the skills he’ll likely be called upon for the upcoming Harry Potter show. Lithgow’s accent work in The Rule of Jenny Pen is impressive, highlighting his ability to mimic other speaking patterns and styles so as not to be distracting from the likely British-heavy production.

There’s a commitment and sincerity to [John Lithgow’s] in-universe performance that will be exciting to see fitted to Dumbledore’s flights of fancy.

Crealy can shift from creepy to kooky with ease, with Lithgow making that change feel like a natural character beat instead of a blunt plot shift. This is something that’s vital to Dumbledore, who would often present himself in the Harry Potter series as a strange old man despite being a steely and resilient figure under the surface. Even when Crealy is at his most bizarre, like when he does a little song and dance number to mock Stefan, there’s a commitment and sincerity to the in-universe performance that will be exciting to see fitted to Dumbledore’s flights of fancy.

Lithgow Could Be The Perfect Person To Bring A Little Darkness To Dumbledore

Lithgow’s Darker Side Could Make Dumbledore More Complex As A Character


The Rule Of Jenny Pen John Lithgow

One of the things that made Dumbledore an interesting character in the original Harry Potter books was the way he proved to be a subversion of the Merlin archetype. Despite being a wise wizard with good intentions, Dumbledore was also prone to moments of pride and selfishness that cost him and others dearly. He was an empathic character who shut off his own emotions, as steadily teased out in more detail in the prequel films. Dumbledore is most compelling when there’s some darkness to him, and Lithgow has the chops to play up both sides of the character.

Lithgow’s experience in comedy makes him a natural fit for the lighter elements of the character, but the darkness he brings to characters like Crealy in The Rule of Jenny Pen highlights the harsher layers that the actor will be able to bring to a character who at first glance appears to be non-threatening. While the characters and performances may end up being very different, Lithgow’s work in The Rule of Jenny Pen is a very reᴀssuring reminder that he has more than enough ability to bring a deceptively complex character like Dumbledore to life.

Related Posts

Uma Thurman’s New Netflix Movie Is A Kill Bill 3 Replacement For Those Who’ve Waited 21 Years For A Tarantino Sequel

Uma Thurman’s New Netflix Movie Is A Kill Bill 3 Replacement For Those Who’ve Waited 21 Years For A Tarantino Sequel

The following contains spoilers for The Old Guard 2.Quentin Tarantino’s two-part action thriller movie, Kill Bill, stars Uma Thurman as ᴀssᴀssin Beatrix Kiddo, also known as the…

James Gunn’s Superman First Social Media Reactions Are Here – See What Critics Are Saying

James Gunn’s Superman First Social Media Reactions Are Here – See What Critics Are Saying

Social media reactions are finally here for James Gunn’s Superman movie, with critics giving their first thoughts on the DC Universe installment with David Corenswet. After years…

Psychological Thriller Becomes #1 Streaming Hit In America Months After M Box Office

Psychological Thriller Becomes #1 Streaming Hit In America Months After $23M Box Office

2025 has been an uneven year for horror movies so far. On the one hand, this year has already had one of the best horror films in…

Zombies 4: Dawn Of The Vampires Review – My Love For The Disney Franchise Has Mostly Avoided Being Tarnished

Zombies 4: Dawn Of The Vampires Review – My Love For The Disney Franchise Has Mostly Avoided Being Tarnished

Zombies 4: Dawn of the Vampires is perhaps the single movie release I was most looking forward to in 2025. I love the Zombies movies, not because…

Stephen King Adaptations That Are Completely Different From His Books

Stephen King Adaptations That Are Completely Different From His Books

Stephen King is one of the most beloved authors of horror and thriller novels, but does the respect for his work always stretch to the adaptations?

One Of The Biggest Deaths For Avengers: Doomsday & Secret Wars Just Became Impossible After Huge MCU Update

One Of The Biggest Deaths For Avengers: Doomsday & Secret Wars Just Became Impossible After Huge MCU Update

The upcoming Avengers movies will not be able to use a major death that had been teased by a Marvel Cinematic Universe star. Avengers: Doomsday and Secret…