Sharpay Was Never The Villain Of High School Musical Villain — Why I (& Every Other Theatre Kid) Will Die On That Hill

If I like the theater and was once a kid, does that make me a theater kid? Certainly not, but I still get to have a say about how villainous Sharpay was in High School Musical, don’t I? After all, with younger sisters, I ended up sitting through all three of the High School Musical movies more times than I care to recall, and while I may have at first pretended the singing romantic movie series was lame, I definitely found myself humming “What I’ve Been Looking For” later in my room. It’s a hard series not to enjoy.

Zac Efron is obviously the biggest star to come out of the High School Musical cast, but the films were stacked with talent. One of the best characters in the High School Musical movies is Sharpay Evans (Ashley Tisdale), and I think that’s inarguable. Not only is Tisdale a fantastic singer and comedic presence, Sharpay is one of the more developed characters in the franchise. I’ve always enjoyed Sharpay’s arc more than any other character, and her journey from catty villain to helpful friend is a pleasure to watch. Honestly, she wasn’t even that mean of a villain.

Sharpay Is Pretty Mellow As Far As Villains Go

Sharpay Is More Self-Centered Than She Is An Actual Bully

I know Sharpay is the villain of High School Musical, but she’s really not all that bad. The first film is Sharpay at her worst. As drama club president, Sharpay has been involved with the musical’s production for the entire year. I may have never been in theater, but I remember friends in the drama club staying late for months preparing for the musical. I’m sure Sharpay has put a lot of time into this. So, when new girl, Gabriella (Vanessa Hudgens), shows up on the scene angling for the lead in the play, is it any wonder Sharpay’s annoyed?

She doesn’t even do anything that bad to get her out of the running. All Sharpay does is direct scholastic decathlon captain, Taylor McKessie (Monique Coleman), to Gabriella and show her what an outstanding student Gabriella is. There’s a world where Sharpay is actually doing the right thing by introducing Gabriella to a club where she can succeed. Sure, she schedules the callback auditions to interfere with Gabriella and Troy’s (Efron) other commitments, but when they manage to make it on time, she accepts the results and even settles on a truce with Gabriella.

Sharpay’s a bit of a snob and definitely self-centered, but who isn’t self-centered at that age?

In High School Musical 2, Sharpay is even less villainous and even finds a way to give her brother the spotlight over herself for once. Sharpay’s a bit of a snob and definitely self-centered, but who isn’t self-centered at that age? She’s no bully. Sharpay is far from the worst bully seen in movies or on TV. Compared to characters like Blair Waldorf in Gossip Girl, Regina George in Mean Girls, and the Heathers in Heathers, Sharpay is downright sweet.

Sharpay Was Right About Not Wanting Troy And Gabriella To Lead The Musical

Troy And Gabriella Have No Musical Experience


Sharpay Evans (Ashley Tisdale) lounging poolside in her pink sunglᴀsses in High School Musical

Also, Sharpay is totally right about Troy and Gabriella. Neither of them has any musical experience. Leading a musical isn’t just singing well. There is much, much more to it than that. They can’t just come into the long-planned event and expect to get the starring role. It doesn’t matter if you have never been in a musical; if you’ve ever participated in any multi-month project, you know few things are more frustrating than someone brand-new coming on the scene and taking all the attention, leap-frogging off your hard work.

Besides, Troy and Gabriella have their own things. Troy has basketball, and Gabriella has the decathlon. Why don’t they skip the musical this year and try out next year with everyone else? That would be much fairer. If the two are so desperate to join the musical, I’m sure there are plenty of other good parts beyond the lead roles that they can take on. Is their need for attention and love for one another so strong that they have to be the co-stars? Just relax, Troy and Gabriella. This isn’t a fun game for Sharpay, she’s put a lot of effort into this.

Sharpay Evans Is A Good Friend To Have

Sharpay Gave All Her Friends Jobs


Sharpay (Ashley Tisdale) & Gabriella (Vanessa Hudgens) Fighting By The Pool In High School Musical 2.jpg

Sharpay’s way of undermining others also happens to be by helping them. Every time she wants to get one over on Troy or Gabriella, she actually ends up helping them. It’s almost as if she would be an awesome friend to have. When Gabriella is new to the school, Sharpay gets her hooked up with the scholastic decathlon team. You know, something she loves and would be good at. In High School Musical 2, Sharpay uses her family connections to set Troy up with someone who could get him an athletic scholarship.

Sharpay Evans is such a good character that she ended up becoming the protagonist of her own spin-off, Sharpay’s Fabulous Adventure​​​​​​.

The only thing she asks for in return is that Troy sings with her. Troy doesn’t have to sing with Gabriella every time. Sharpay gets everyone from her high school a job at her family’s country club. Sure, she’s a bit of a snob about it, but I would have killed to work all summer at a country club with my friends. I think Sharpay getting a duet with Troy is a fair trade. Someone like Sharpay is someone you roll your eyes at when she’s being annoying but hug anyway because, at her core, she’s a good friend.

A Lot Of Modern Female Protagonists Have Shades Of Sharpay

Ambition And Self-Confidence Are Good Things For A Character To Have


Ashley Tisdale As Sharpay Evans smiling in High School Musical.

Sharpay Evans was ahead of her time in terms of movie and TV female protagonists. She’s ambitious, wants what she wants, and isn’t afraid to come off as a little pushy to do so. Shows and movies are filled with similar characters now, and they are usually treated as the protagonist. Deborah Vance in Hacks, Midge Maisel in The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, and Joy Mangano in Joy are all characters who fit the Sharpay mold from High School Musical, so it’s nice to see that we’re showcasing them as the inspiring leaders they are, rather than the villains.

Related Posts

Charlize Theron’s Netflix Action Movie With 80% RT Score Lands On Global Charts As Sequel Release Nears

Charlize Theron’s Netflix Action Movie With 80% RT Score Lands On Global Charts As Sequel Release Nears

A movie released on Netflix five years ago, with an 80% Rotten Tomatoes score, has re-entered the global charts as its sequel prepares to drop. The Netflix…

Downton Abbey: The Grand Finale’s Trailers Are Hiding One Major Character – Why?

Downton Abbey: The Grand Finale’s Trailers Are Hiding One Major Character – Why?

Both Downton Abbey: The Grand Finale‘s teaser trailer and its first official full-length trailer are hiding one of the franchise’s most important characters, but why? Downton Abbey:…

Face It, Star Wars’ Next Movie Is NOT Going To End This Way

Face It, Star Wars’ Next Movie Is NOT Going To End This Way

Although we’re still a year away from Star Wars’ next movie, The Mandalorian and Grogu, there are still plenty of fan theories about the upcoming film. One…

When Superman, Batman & Wonder Woman Will Get Their First DC Universe Crossover Addressed By James Gunn

When Superman, Batman & Wonder Woman Will Get Their First DC Universe Crossover Addressed By James Gunn

James Gunn shares when the DC Universe audience could expect to see Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman unite in the new franchise. As the DCU’s Chapter 1:…

Christopher Nolan & Denis Villeneuve’s Careers Are Weirdly Similar: 10 Odd Parallels

Christopher Nolan & Denis Villeneuve’s Careers Are Weirdly Similar: 10 Odd Parallels

Christopher Nolan and Denis Villeneuve are two of the most celebrated directors in cinema today. Both are renowned for their cerebral approaches to blockbuster filmmaking, and for…

How & When Superman Could Appear In An R-Rated DC Universe Release Addressed By DCU Actor David Corenswet

How & When Superman Could Appear In An R-Rated DC Universe Release Addressed By DCU Actor David Corenswet

Superman star David Corenswet opens up about how and when his Man of Steel could take part in an R-rated DC Universe project. With the DCU timeline…