New study reveals the first English settlers in North America ate dogs with indigenous ancestry

A recent study published in American Antiquity by researchers from the University of Iowa revealed that the first English settlers to arrive in North America resorted to eating indigenous dogs to survive an extreme period of starvation.

New study reveals the first English settlers in North America ate dogs with indigenous ancestryA scene of a street in Jamestown, circa 1650 (Keith Rocco, artist). Credit: National Park Service

The study, conducted by a team led by Ariane E. Thomas, a Ph.D. candidate at the University of Iowa, analyzed genetic material from archaeological specimens of dogs that lived in Jamestown between 1609 and 1617 CE.

The researchers uncovered surprising evidence that at least six dogs in Jamestown had unmistakable Native American ancestry and were consumed by the settlers during a period of severe starvation known as the Starving Time. These dogs shared genetic similarities with canines from the Hopewellian, Mississippian, and Late Woodland periods of eastern North America.

This discovery suggests that early European colonists heavily relied on local Indigenous groups for survival, especially during the initial settlement phase. The presence of Indigenous dogs in Jamestown reflects a more complex relationship between the British settlers and the Powhatan people than previously ᴀssumed.

New study reveals the first English settlers in North America ate dogs with indigenous ancestryComposite map of butchery and impact marks across dog skeletons. Credit: Ariane E. Thomas et al. American Antiquity (2024)

The archaeological evidence, including bone modifications consistent with butchering and consumption, indicates that the settlers resorted to eating dogs during times of extreme hardship. This practice, while taboo in modern Western societies, was not uncommon in Europe during periods of stress.

The Starving Time, marked by food shortages, disease, violence with Indigenous tribes, and harsh environmental conditions, took a devastating toll on the Jamestown community, with up to 90% of the settlers perishing. George Percy, one of the original colonists, documented the desperation of the time, including instances of cannibalism and the consumption of vermin and domestic animals.

Furthermore, the genetic analysis of the dogs highlights the social entanglement between colonizers and Indigenous communities. Dogs served as both a connection and a source of tension between the two cultures.

Lead researcher Ariane E. Thomas said: “The ancestry of the Jamestown dogs provides insight into European and Indigenous management of their dogs. Dogs with ancestry predominantly from Europe suggest that either British, Powhatan, or both groups kept their dogs from interacting with each other to maintain specific behaviors or observable phenotypes important to that group.

“Identifying Indigenous dogs at Jamestown suggests a more complex engagement between the British and Powhatan peoples… This second, more complex dynamic is more representative of history,” she added.

More information: Thomas AE, Hill ME, Stricker L, et al. (2024). The Dogs of Tsenacomoco: Ancient DNA Reveals the Presence of Local Dogs at Jamestown Colony in the Early Seventeenth Century. American Antiquity:1-19. doi:10.1017/aaq.2024.25

Related Posts

Ancient shipwrecks rewrite 500 years of Iron Age Mediterranean trade

Ancient shipwrecks rewrite 500 years of Iron Age Mediterranean trade

Archaeologists from the University of California at San Diego and the University of Haifa have discovered the oldest known Iron Age ship cargoes found in a known…

Ancient stone tools show Europe’s early humans innovated independently from the Near East 42,000 years ago

Ancient stone tools show Europe’s early humans innovated independently from the Near East 42,000 years ago

About 42,000 years ago, early modern humans across Europe and the Near East began producing remarkably similar types of stone tools. Archaeologists had long ᴀssumed that these…

Ancient birch tar reveals how Europe’s first farmers chewed, cooked, and crafted 6,000 years ago

Ancient birch tar reveals how Europe’s first farmers chewed, cooked, and crafted 6,000 years ago

In Neolithic Europe, long before writing or metal tools, people relied on an incredible substance—birch bark tar. A new study, published in Proceedings of the Royal Society…

Roman hospital transformed into Byzantine church unearthed in ancient city of Kaunos

Roman hospital transformed into Byzantine church unearthed in ancient city of Kaunos

Archaeologists in southwestern Turkey have uncovered an astonishing architectural transformation in the ancient city of Kaunos—one that spans more than a millennium of history. Excavations near the…

Satellite images reveal 76 ancient hunting traps in Chile, uncovering millennia of survival in the Andes

Satellite images reveal 76 ancient hunting traps in Chile, uncovering millennia of survival in the Andes

Satellite imagery has revealed 76 ancient stone hunting traps and hundreds of previously unseen settlements in the high-alтιтude Andes of northern Chile—evidence that hunting and gathering persisted…

Archaeologists discover one of Egypt’s largest New Kingdom fortresses in North Sinai

Archaeologists discover one of Egypt’s largest New Kingdom fortresses in North Sinai

Archaeologists in Egypt have uncovered a large New Kingdom fortress at Tell El-Kharouba in North Sinai, near the town of Sheikh Zuweid and the Gaza border. The…