Why Benedict Cumberbatch’s Horror-Drama Makes Changes From Its Book Explained By Star & Director: “The Book’s Really Unusual”

Throughout the 2010s, Benedict Cumberbatch proved that he is one of the best actors working today. Cumberbatch’s best movies include The Imitation Game, The Courier, The Power of the Dog, and the 2023 Wes Anderson-helmed short film The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar. Cumberbatch has been praised for numerous roles throughout his career, and was even nominated for a Best Actor Oscar for his work in The Imitation Game and The Power of the Dog.

In 2016, Cumberbatch also debuted his version of Doctor Strange in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Cumberbatch has appeared in six MCU movies and Doctor Strange has become one of the most popular characters in the sprawling franchise. Cumberbatch’s most recent MCU movie, 2022’s Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, contains many horror sequences. However, Cumberbatch is not necessarily known for starring in horror movies. This could change in 2025 after the release of a Cumberbatch-led film that will also contain elements of horror.

The Thing With Feathers Star & Director Discuss Their Upcoming Movie

The Thing With Feathers Makes Changes To The Novel

Cumberbatch and director Dylan Southern recently compared their upcoming horror-drama film, The Thing With Feathers to the book it is based on. The film is an adaptation of the 2015 novel Grief Is the Thing with Feathers by author Max Porter, and follows a father and two sons who must handle the sudden loss of their wife and mother. The Thing with Feathers premiered at the Sundance Film Festival on January 25, 2025, but it has not yet been announced when it will receive a wide release.

Screen Rant‘s Grant Hermanns was present at the Sundance Film Festival and spoke with Cumberbatch and Southern about how The Thing with Feathers differs from the novel. Both Cumberbatch and Southern praise the novel, but admit it was difficult to adapt, since Grief Is the Thing with Feathers is an unconventional book that is told from three different perspectives. Cumberbatch and Southern tease that their upcoming movie had to make changes from the original novel. Read their full comments below:

Cumberbatch: It’s just a startling original novel. It’s just the most formally playful, inventive and kind of unique way of expressing something that’s — I think, in the milieu of middle class, middle-aged Brit, it’s quite locked away sometimes, and Max Porter, the novelist, found this amazing kind of metaphor through Ted Hughes’ poems, and this academic succession with them. He slowly realized in the book that it’s all really about the boys. It’s an unreliable narration, it’s about their memory of what happened to their father and what it felt like being around this man who was obsessed with the crow collection of poems at the time, and with our version, Dylan had the master stroke — and he’s really big graphic novel fan — of making my character, Dad, an illustrator, an artist who’s bringing out this book based on inspired by the crow series of poems. So, that’s an immediate extrapolation between that being tactile and realizable on the page to being something in the room.

Southern: It was a process, really. The book’s really unusual, it’s written from three different perspectives. It’s a mixture of prose and poetry, it uses different tenses, it spans multiple years. It’s not an obvious translation to a movie story. So I think it was embracing all of those things and realizing that I could kind of take it wherever I wanted to was the thing that unlocked it, and also the support of Max. Max didn’t have to option the book to me, but he did. He was always there as much or as little as I needed him. In the end, he was blown away by the first draft, and just kept me going. He’s a really good collaborator, so it was good to have him on the side.

Our Take On Cumberbatch & Southern’s Comments About The Thing With Feathers

The Thing With Feathers Could Be Great


Benedict Cumberbatch making his hand into a claw in The Thing With Feathers

The Thing with Feathers is based on a critically acclaimed novel and has an intriguing premise. Additionally, Cumberbatch has consistently proven his ability to give strong performances. Therefore, The Thing with Feathers could be a great movie. The film was one of the most anticipated horror films premiering at Sundance, so hopefully The Thing with Feathers can receive a wide release sooner rather than later.

Related Posts

A Complete Unknown Is The Perfect Double Feature With This Coen Brothers Movie With 92% On RT

A Complete Unknown Is The Perfect Double Feature With This Coen Brothers Movie With 92% On RT

A Complete Unknown’s encapsulation of the New York folk scene of the 1960s makes it the perfect double feature with a different musical drama by the Coen…

How 2015’s Older Marty McFly Got Injured In Back To The Future Part II

How 2015’s Older Marty McFly Got Injured In Back To The Future Part II

When Back to the Future Part II shows Marty McFly’s possible fate in 2015, it reveals that his life was ruined by an injury he sustained in…

The Godfather’s Original Casting Choice For A Minor Character Would Have Ruined The Godfather Part II

The Godfather’s Original Casting Choice For A Minor Character Would Have Ruined The Godfather Part II

If a certain legendary actor had gotten the small role he was considered for in The Godfather, then it would’ve prevented one of the best castings in…

This 1981 Classic With 98% On Rotten Tomatoes Is Undoubtedly The Greatest Submarine War Movie Of All Time

This 1981 Classic With 98% On Rotten Tomatoes Is Undoubtedly The Greatest Submarine War Movie Of All Time

There have been some really great war movies set on submarines, but the 1981 classic Das Boot is undeniably the greatest submarine film ever made. Das Boot…

I’m Really Glad These Directors Didn’t Make These 10 Movies They Were Attached To

I’m Really Glad These Directors Didn’t Make These 10 Movies They Were Attached To

I have boundless respect for the craft and creativity of directors in Hollywood, but not every director is a perfect fit for specific projects. The director of…

These 10 Classic Movies Got Sequels, But You Didn’t See Them On The Big Screen

These 10 Classic Movies Got Sequels, But You Didn’t See Them On The Big Screen

While today, franchises are rife in Hollywood, many of the biggest classic films never got a sequel on the big screen, despite the story continuing elsewhere. There…