As the burgeoning genre picks up steam, Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare is yet another low-budget mascot horror film in the Twisted Childhood Universe. Based on the beloved children’s character created by Scottish author J.M. Barrie in 1902, Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare is the latest in a long line of modern horror flicks to take characters aimed at youngsters and turn them into the stuff of nightmares. Scott Jeffrey helms the movie, and it comes from the team behind Winnie the Pooh: Blood and Honey.

The mascot horror genre was kicked into high gear with the release of the aforementioned horror spoof in 2023, and shocked the world when Winnie the Pooh: Blood and Honey was a box office hit. Naturally, Jagged Edge Productions (the company behind Blood and Honey) wanted to strike while the iron was H๏τ. Therefore, they have green-lit not only a sequel but a Peter Pan film set in the same universe. Jagged Edge takes viewers to the dark side of Neverland and here are all the details about the stomach-churning horror opus.

Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare Box Office & Critical Reception

Not Quite The Splash That Blood & Honey Made

Representing the next big step for Jagged Edge and their Twisted Childhood Universe, the reception to Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare has been somewhat tepid. While Blood and Honey and its sequel got a lot of attention for its edgy gore and over-the-top spoofing, Neverland Nightmare hasn’t garnered nearly the same reaction. Perhaps illustrating how audiences have already been desensitized to the mascot horror genre, the handful of professional reviews the movie has received have been middling.

Not quite getting enough reviews to earn a score on Rotten Tomatoes, the movie did get a full write-up from IGN who was less than impressed. The publication wrote that the movie was far too referential to previous horror properties to feel original, and that the entire concept comes off as mean-spirited and lacking the fun of Blood and Honey. JoBlo specifically mentioned that Martin Portlock’s performance seemed to be a carbon copy of Heath Ledger’s beloved Joker in The Dark Knight, while also echoing many of the sentiments in IGN‘s review.

As for the movie’s box office, no numbers have been reported yet because of the movie’s very limited three-day release schedule. However, it’s clear that Neverland Nightmare will be walking a razor-thin margin of success and failure when it comes to box office success. Though Blood and Honey made a lot of money for such a low budget movie, Neverland Nightmare had a bigger budget and would need to make more to succeed.

• Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare Review: The Blood & Honey Universe Thrives Only When It Leans Into Being Completely Unhinged
• Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare Can Beat Winnie-The-Pooh: Blood & Honey

Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare Cast

The Stars Of Neverland Nightmare

The movies produced by Jagged Edge Productions often rely on relative newcomers to flesh out their casts, but Neverland Nightmare does feature a recognizable name or two. Leading the cast is Megan Placito as Wendy Darling, the daring hero who tries to rescue her brother from Peter Pan (played by Martin Portlock). Peter DeSouza-Feighoney plays Wendy’s younger brother Michael, and Kit Green appears as a drug-addicted Tinkerbell. RuPaul’s Drag Race alum Charity Kase transforms into a nightmarish version of Captain James Hook.

The cast of Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare includes:

Actor	Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare Role
Martin Portlock	Peter Pan
Megan Placito	Wendy Darling
Peter DeSouza-Feighoney	Michael Darling
Kit Green	Tinkerbell
Charity Kase	Captain James Hook
Teresa Banham	Mary Darling
Nicholas Woodeson	Steven
Kierston Wareing	Roxy
Olumide Olorunfemi	Tiger Lily

• Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare Images Reveal First Look At Tinker Bell & Captain Hook In Blood & Honey Universe’s New Movie
• Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare’s Peter DeSouza-Feighoney Was “Shocked” At Latest TCU Installment

Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare Trailer

Watch The Full Trailer Below

In anticipation of the movie’s 2025 release, a full trailer for Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare was revealed in early September 2024. The trailer opens with Peter kidnapping a little boy before going on a murder spree as he plans to send his victims to “Neverland”. What’s clear from the trailer is that the production value has been upgraded, and that Jagged Edge’s take on Peter Pan may be even more perverse than their previous outings.

Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare Ending & Spoilers

Peter Pan Will Return In Poohniverse: Monsters ᴀssemble

Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare is the latest in Jagged Edge’s Twisted Childhood movies but its ending made it clear that it won’t be the last. After a host of classic horror battles and bloody confrontations, the finale was the sort of twist that is found in nearly every other movie in the subgenre. With it already confirmed that Peter, Hook, and others will appear in Poohniverse: Monsters ᴀssemble, it shouldn’t come as much of a surprise that the murderous version of Pan is still on the loose.

• Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare’s Scott Chambers Reveals Major TCU Crossover Plans
• Poohniverse: Monsters ᴀssemble – Confirmation, Cast & Everything We Know